4441
AssignmentLong Text

Impact of the Crusades

Question 4441 • TX-World History Studies

In one paragraph, compare and contrast the similarities and differences found in the two accounts, and explain which account is more reliable.Use reasons and evidence from the readings to support your claim.

Answer

Answer:

Both accounts describe the Franks killing many people in Jerusalem and people taking refuge at the Tower of David and the Temple of Solomon. They differ in the reported death toll: Ibn al-Athir says more than 70,000 were killed at al-Aqsa, while Fulcher says almost 10,000 were killed in the temple. Ibn al-Athir also says the group at the Tower of David was allowed to leave after surrendering, whereas Fulcher emphasizes that women and children were not spared. Fulcher’s lower estimate and more specific description make his account somewhat more plausible, but both writers had perspectives that could shape their accounts, so the exact numbers are uncertain.