Experimental Designs Answers

0 verified answers1 views
1
Free Preview

A therapist wants to study the effects of yoga and meditation on stress relief. She has 60 volunteers who experience varying levels of stress. Half of the participants will be assigned to practice yoga for one month and the other half will practice meditation. Before the experiment begins, all of the participants will be asked to rate their stress levels on a scale from 0 to 10, with 0 representing "no stress” and 10 representing "highest level of stress.” The therapist believes that current stress levels could affect the results; therefore, she has the subjects participate in both treatments. For each subject, a coin is flipped. If it lands on heads, then the subject will practice yoga for the first half of the month and meditation for the last half of the month. If it lands on tails, the subject will practice meditation for the first half of the month and yoga for the last half. Stress levels are measured before switching treatments and again at the end of the month. The differences in stress levels will be compared.

A
Yes, each subject is randomly assigned both treatments.
B
Yes, each subject was asked to rate their stress level at the beginning of the experiment.
C
Yes, but the effects of the first treatment may affect the results of the second treatment.
D
No, the subjects’ stress levels before the beginning of the experiment may affect the results.
2
Free Preview

A new cream was developed to reduce the irritation caused by poison ivy. To test the effectiveness, researchers placed an ad online asking for volunteers to participate in the study, and 100 subjects replied. They are informed that one group will receive a new cream and the other group will receive a cream with no active ingredient. The researchers believe that sun exposure may affect the cream’s effectiveness. The subjects are then asked about their outdoor activities, and 42 of the subjects state they spend more than 50% of their day outside. All subjects are exposed to poison ivy and given their cream. They are asked to return in three days and report their level of irritation.

A
The subjects are grouped based on their outdoor activity. The 42 subjects are randomly assigned to the two treatment groups. The remaining 58 subjects are also randomly assigned to the two treatment groups.
B
The subjects are numbered 1–100, and these numbers are entered into a random number generator. Fifty numbers, ignoring repeats, are generated and these subjects receive the new cream. The remaining 50 receive the inactive cream.
C
The subjects are paired based on similar age. Two marbles, one red and one blue, are placed in a bag and mixed. If the first subject picks a red marble, then that subject will receive the new cream and the other subject will receive the inactive cream. If it is blue, then the opposite will occur. This is done for all 50 pairs.
D
The subjects are grouped based on their outdoor activity. The researchers flip a coin and if it lands on heads, then the group with the most sun exposure will receive the new cream and the other group will receive the inactive cream. If the coin lands on tails, then the group with the most sun exposure will receive the inactive cream and the other group will receive the new cream.
3

A tire company wants to determine if tires made with a new type of tread will last longer than the tires made with the original type of tread. The company has access to 24 different vehicles. The vehicles will be driven for one year and the depth of the remaining tread will be measured. The average depth for the new type of tread will be compared to the average depth of the original type of tread.

A
There are six vehicles of each vehicle type: sedan, SUV, minivan, and truck. For each type, three vehicles will be randomly selected to receive tires with the new tread and the other three vehicles will receive tires with the original tread.
B
Each vehicle is numbered 1–24, and these numbers are put into a random number generator. The first 12 unique numbers represent the vehicles that will receive the tires with the new tread. The remaining 12 vehicles will receive the tires with the original tread.
C
The vehicles will be put in groups of two based on the size of the vehicle, with the largest two put together, the next largest two, etc. For each of the 12 pairs, the largest vehicle will get tires with the original type of tread and the other vehicle in the pair will get the new type of tread.
D
There are six vehicles of each vehicle type: sedan, SUV, minivan, and truck. Each vehicle type is numbered 1–4, and these numbers are entered into a random number generator. The first two unique numbers selected will represent the group of vehicles that will receive tires with the new type of tread. The remaining 2 groups will receive tires with the original tread.
4

A tire company wants to determine if tires made with a new type of tread will last longer than the tires made with the original type of tread. The company has access to 24 different vehicles. The vehicles will be driven for one year and the depth of the remaining tread will be measured. The average depth for the new type of tread will be compared to the average depth of the original type of tread.

A
Each of the 24 vehicles is numbered 1–24. These numbers are put into a random number generator. The first 12 unique numbers generated will represent the vehicles that will receive the tires with the new tread. The remaining 12 vehicles will receive the tires with the original tread.
B
There are six vehicles of each vehicle type: sedan, SUV, minivan, and truck. For each type, the vehicles will be numbered 1–6, and a random number generator will be used to pick three unique numbers. These three vehicles will receive tires with the new tread and the other three vehicles in the group will receive tires with the original tread.
C
There are six vehicles of each vehicle type: sedan, SUV, minivan, and truck. Each vehicle type is numbered 1–4, and these numbers are entered into a random number generator. The first two unique numbers selected will represent the group of vehicles that will receive tires with the new type of tread. The remaining two groups will receive tires with the original type of tread.
D
The vehicles will be put into groups of two based on the size of the vehicle, with the largest two put together, the next largest two, etc. For each of the 12 groups of two, one of the vehicles is selected and a coin will be flipped. If it is heads, this car will receive tires with the new tread and the other vehicle will receive tires with the original tread. If it is tails, then the opposite will be done.
5

A florist wants to determine if a new additive helps extend the life of cut flowers longer than the original additive does. The florist selects 20 flowers of different types and puts each flower in its own vase with the same amount of water. She positions the vases so they also receive the same exposure to light. She numbers the flowers 1–20, and places these numbers on equal-sized slips of paper. The slips are placed in a hat and mixed thoroughly. A slip is chosen and the corresponding flower receives the new additive. After the hat is shaken, another slip is chosen and the corresponding flower also receives the new additive. This procedure continues until 10 flowers have been assigned to receive the new additive. The remaining 10 flowers receive the original additive.

A
Yes, each flower is randomly assigned to the treatments.
B
Yes, the flowers were placed in their own vases, and received the same amount of water and light.
C
No, only 20 flowers were used in the experiment.
D
No, the flowers were not put into groups first and then randomly assigned the two additives.
6

A veterinarian knows that the supplement glucosamine is beneficial for dogs’ joints. He wants to determine if a supplement with both glucosamine and chondroitin would be more beneficial than glucosamine alone for dogs’ joint health. The veterinarian asks the owners of dogs with known joint issues if they would be willing to have their dog participate in his study, and 32 owners agree to the study. Sixteen dogs are randomly assigned to the glucosamine group and the remaining 16 are assigned to the glucosamine with chondroitin group. After 6 months, the dogs’ joint health is measured for each treatment and compared. The results of the study were inconclusive and the veterinarian decides to do the experiment again. He gets 24 volunteers and decides that he needs to use a randomized block design.

A
age
B
size
C
color of coat
D
breed
7

A veterinarian knows that the supplement glucosamine is beneficial for dogs’ joints. He wants to determine if a supplement with both glucosamine and chondroitin would be more beneficial than glucosamine alone for dogs’ joint health. The veterinarian asks the owners of dogs with known joint issues if they would be willing to have their dog participate in his study, and 32 owners agree to the study. The veterinarian also knows that breed and age may affect the results of the experiment.

A
Completely randomized design: Randomly assign the treatments to the dogs.
B
Matched pairs design: Block the dogs based on breed. Then, within each block, pair the dogs based on age. Randomly assign the treatments to each dog in the pairs.
C
Randomized block design: Block the dogs based on breed. Then, randomly assign half of the dogs in each block to receive glucosamine only and the other half to receive glucosamine with chondroitin.
D
Observational study: The veterinarian should randomly select patient records. Then, use the joint health of dogs that use glucosamine only and those that use glucosamine with chondroitin.
8

A shoe company wants to test an updated model of a running shoe on its wear after one month of running. They recruit 50 people who run on a regular basis to participate in the study. They will have the runners wear the shoes when they run for two months. After two months, the wear on the shoes will be determined using the depth of the tread and flexibility of the toe box. The wear between the new model and the original model will then be compared. The company decides to use a matched pairs design and devises two options.Option A: The 50 subjects are paired based on running ability. The fastest two runners are paired together, the next fastest two, etc. For each pair of runners, the researcher will flip a coin. If the coin lands on heads, then the first runner will receive the new model of shoes and the second runner will receive the original model. If the coin lands on tails, the first runner will receive the original model of shoes and the second runner will receive the new model. After 2 months of use, the difference in wear for the pairs of runners will be determined.Option B: The 50 subjects will each receive both models of shoes. At the beginning, the runner will flip a coin, and if it lands on heads, they will wear the new model on their right foot and the original model on their left foot. Then after one month, they will change and use the new model on their left foot and the original model on their right foot. After the second month, the wear for each model will be determined and compared for the 50 runners.

A
A: The runners are paired based on their running ability. This will provide an accurate comparison for the difference in wear between the original model and the new model.
B
B: Each runner varies with respect to multiple variables. Each runner should use both models to account for their individual differences. This will provide an accurate comparison for the difference in wear between the models.
C
Both A and B: Both provide an accurate comparison for the difference in wear between the original model and the new model. The runners are paired in option A based on running ability, and each runner uses both models in option B.
D
Neither A nor B: Neither provides an accurate comparison to determine the difference in wear for the two models. This experiment should be a randomized block design.
9

A biology student wants to determine if using a fertilizer would help promote the growth of new babies in spider plants. The student chooses 100 baby spider plants to be used in the study. They all are potted in the same amount and type of soil, given the same amount of water, and exposed to the same amount of light. Half of the plants are randomly assigned to the group that receives fertilizer every three months and the remaining plants are assigned to the group that does not receive fertilizer. After one year, the shoots are counted for each plant. The average number of shoots for the plants receiving fertilizer is compared with the average number of shoots for the plants that did not receive fertilizer.

A
Yes, the plants were randomly assigned each treatment.
B
Yes, the plants received the same amount of soil, water, and light.
C
No, only spider plants were used.
D
No, the plants did not all receive the same treatment.
10

A new cream was developed to reduce the irritation caused by poison ivy. To test the effectiveness, researchers placed an ad online asking volunteers to participate in the study, and 100 subjects replied. They are informed that one group of 50 will receive a new cream and the remaining group of 50 will receive a cream with no active ingredient. As each subject enters the study facility, the researchers flip a coin. Heads means the subject goes to room A and tails means the subject goes to room B. The subjects in room A will receive the new cream and the subjects in room B will receive the inactive cream. All subjects are exposed to poison ivy and given their cream. They are asked to return in three days and report their level of irritation.

A
Yes, the subjects will all be exposed to poison ivy and then apply the cream.
B
Yes, the subjects are receiving either the new cream or the inactive cream.
C
No, the subjects are asked to return in three days. It is possible that some may not return, which will introduce bias into the results.
D
Yes, the subjects are assigned to the two treatment groups completely by chance.

Did you find these answers helpful?